Best Real Estate Agents in Elmira, Ontario, Canada in May 2026

25 local real estate agent reviews in Elmira with an average rating of 5/5

Elmira's highest-reviewed real estate agents in May 2026, based on 25 verified client reviews submitted through RankMyAgent, include Rachel Paquette, Tracey Appleton, and Jason O'Keefe. Rankings reflect verified transaction reviews, review recency, review volume, and overall client satisfaction to help buyers and sellers find trusted Elmira REALTORS®.
Recommended in Elmira Most Reviews Trending in Elmira
Individuals Teams Offices
Buying Selling Buying and Selling Renting
Detached Homes Condos (High & Low Rise) Townhomes & Semi-Detached Luxury Real Estate Commercial Properties First-Time Home Buyers Downsizing & Seniors Upsizing & Family Moves Military & Relocation Pre-Construction & Presales New Build Homes Custom Homes & In-fill Investment Properties Multi-family (2-4 Units) Fixer-Uppers & Foreclosures Rentals & Student Housing Rent-to-Own Acreage & Rural Land Waterfront, Recreational and Cottages Eco-friendly & Net-Zero Estate Sales & Probate Accessible & Inclusive Housing
American Sign Language Arabic Bengali Cantonese Croatian Danish Dutch English Estonian Finnish French German Greek Gujarati Hebrew Hindi Hungarian Italian Japanese Korean Latvian Lithuanian Malayalam Mandarin Norwegian Persian Polish Portuguese Punjabi Romanian Russian Serbian Spanish Swedish Tagalog Tamil Telugu Turkish Ukrainian Urdu Vietnamese
Individuals
Selling
All Results
Rachel Paquette
Rachel Paquette

REMAX Twin City Realty Inc.

4.98/5

159 verified reviews

 2025 award winner

50% of reviews for Buying

3 years ago

As co-executor we were responsible for selling a home and vacant property behind the home. We interviewed 2 agents and Rachel hands down was our choice! She impressed me with her preparedness during our interview and...

Read full review
Tracey Appleton
Tracey Appleton

Royal LePage Wolle Realty

5.00/5

37 verified reviews

 2022 award winner

Tracey hasn't received any reviews for Elmira yet.
Jason O'Keefe
Jason O'Keefe

Real Broker Ontario Ltd.

4.95/5

9 verified reviews

Jason hasn't received any reviews for Elmira yet.
Ivan Gascho
Ivan Gascho

Edge Realty Solutions

No reviews yet
Ivan hasn't received any reviews for Elmira yet.
Natalia Podolean
Natalia Podolean

REMAX Real Estate Centre Inc

5.00/5

1 verified reviews

Natalia hasn't received any reviews for Elmira yet.